Tag Archives: sharon d clarke

Caroline, or Change (Playhouse Theatre)

poster image for Caroline or Change

The Chichester Theatre production of this accomplished musical has just announced it closes a month early to make room for the transfer of Fiddler on the Roof from the Menier, but I would recommend you take advantage of the deals and discounts now available to see Caroline, or Change, if you can.

Planned for several years, and written by Angels in America author Tony Kushner, this show was originally planned as an opera but instead grew into a stage musical, largely sung-through, composed by Jeanine Tesori (her previous show, Violet, is also in town, and I will report back on that next month).

Dujonna Gift-Simms, Ako Mitchell, Tanisha Spring, Sharon D Clarke
Dujonna Gift-Simms, Ako Mitchell, Tanisha Spring, Sharon D Clarke

Caroline (Sharon D Clarke) is a black maid who works for a rich Jewish family, the Gellmans. She is a widow with three children of her own, who live in poverty under the shadow of the Confederate Statue we see as the play opens, a symbol of the white privilege which stops the likes of Caroline and her friend Dotty (Naana Agyei-Ampadu) from getting on in life.

The opening scene proper gives a sense of the unusual: there is a singing washing-machine, a dryer, and eventually, the lady in the moon. This gives a sense of the fantastic to Caroline’s mundane day of cleaning and doing the laundry.

Me'sha Bryan and Sharon D Clarke
Me’sha Bryan and Sharon D Clarke

We are also introduced to Noah, the spoiled young man of the house (Aaron Gelkoff at this performance), who misses his dead mother, resents his cookie-cut stepmother (Lauren Ward), and enjoys sharing an illicit daily cigarette with Caroline.

Noah has a habit of leaving loose change in his pockets, and this is the “change” which is depicted in the title; he seeks attention by leaving the change for Caroline (who is allowed by Rose, the wife, to keep it), and she takes the opportunity to treat her children to the treats they would otherwise go without.

Sharon D Clarke and Abiona Omonua in Caroline or Change
Sharon D Clarke and Abiona Omonua in Caroline or Change

Politics intrude now and then – the assassination of JFK, who was on the side of civil liberties, and a Chanukah celebration which touches on racial politics, with an argument between Mr Stopnick, Rose’s father (Teddy Kempner) and Emmie, Caroline’s growing daughter (Abiona Omonua) – but what matters is the bond between people, and the aspiration for change in the literal sense.

Noah’s father (Alastair Brookshaw) plays the clarinet and hides his grief; his parents (Vincent Pirillo and Sue Kelvin) add pointed commentary, and Noah grows to find his place in the natural order of things; still, by the ending it seems Caroline has achieved her change, set aside the memories of the sailor she lost, and found her place.

The songs are largely memoraable and vibrant – highlights would include Lot’s Wife, I Hate the Bus, and the Laundry Quintet, with the Radio girls who form a kind of chorus. Clarke is an acting and singing powerhouse, and Omonua is impressive, and all the children do well with their routines.

An informative programme (£5) gives the cultural background on the time depicted, and the genesis of the show.


Ghost – The Musical (Piccadilly Theatre)

Originally published on my LiveJournal blog on 3 August 2011.

The 1990 film of ‘Ghost’, directed by Jerry Zucker, starring Patrick Swazye, Demi Moore, and Whoopi Goldberg, was the massive hit of that year.  Writer Bruce Joel Rubin again does the writing duties in this musical version, which has songs by Dave Stewart (formerly of The Eurythmics), and Glen Ballard.

Caissie Levy and Richard Fleeshman in Ghost.
Caissie Levy and Richard Fleeshman in Ghost.

In the leads this time are British actor Richard Fleeshman, American singer Caissie Levy, and British musical star Sharon D Clarke.  For me, Clarke stole the show as the brassy psychic fake who freaks out when she discovers her family ‘gift’ is real.  She has one knockout number ‘I’m Outta Here’ in which a naughty dig at Whitney Houston raises a smile, and generally radiates energy – and real pathos when it is needed in the closing scenes.  As for the leads – Fleeshman takes time to settle into his role.  Once he becomes the ‘ghost’ he rails against his fate with some justification, but is let down a bit by songs which aren’t needed.  Levy, although an able actress, is a little shrilly when it comes to the high notes (something I noticed when she sang ‘Easy To Be Hard’ as Sheila in last year’s revival of ‘Hair’).  

I felt that ‘Ghost – The Musical’ suffered a bit from what I call ‘Gone-With-The-Wind-syndrome’ in that in the first half at least there seems to be a song to back up every piece of dialogue.  Far too much is City/office based in a sub-‘Enron’ style with numbers flashing in video projection and staccato choreography.  In the second half things move along more quickly as the plot develops and the conclusion is truly moving.  Throughout video projection, magic tricks, and spectacle fill the senses and provide the wow factor.

In the beautifully re-fitted Piccadilly Theatre (with art deco features and a green/gold colour scheme) the audience were impressed enough to give a standing ovation, although I didn’t think this musical quite deserved it!  It’s a reasonable night out – it looks as if money has been thrown at it, and it keeps the plot of the original film intact (although rearranged slightly).  It has some nice tricks concerning the transfer of souls after death (and some nice bits of comedy), but at its heart it is spectacle over substance.  And without any hummable songs other than ‘Unchained Melody’, which is retained from the film as is the clay-making sequence.

Silents, Please!

interesting avenues in silent film history

View from the Cheap Seat

News, reviews and opinion from the cheapest seat

Adventure Travel Nepal

Nepal tour operator and trekking agent




Two girls one trip

Simply Eleonore

Your typical spleepy bi vegan intersectional feminist

ECBC Manchester

Fighting the Darkness of Mental Illness with Manchester Spirit

%d bloggers like this: