The story of Henry McCarty, aka William H Bonney, aka Billy The Kid, has passed into Western folklore, along with the only universally accepted portrait of him, given to his associate Dan Dedrick and purchased at auction by William Koch in 2011.
Frank Abrams’ story begins at a flea market when he spots and purchases a set of tintypes to decorate a wall in his house. It was the same year as the Koch auction, but these tintypes cost just £10.
It seems like a tall tale on the surface. A group of cowboys mugging for the camera, Google searches, ancestral research, handwriting experts, historical revision. The Abrams tintype in question allegedly depicts Billy The Kid alongside Pat Garrett, the man who would eventually gun him down.
Facial recognition analysts and academics worked with Abrams to work out identification and provenance, yet the Wild West industry and associations preferred to stick to their “all tintypes are fake” position.
The Slander of Billy The Kid and the Abrams Tintypes not only recounts a decade-long quest to be taken seriously but also offers speculation about Billy’s life and legend. He was just 22 years old when he was gunned down. He had killed men, certainly, but Abrams challenges Garrett’s account and suggests he had just cause.
The frustration of both attempting to rehabilitate a Western legend and prove the discovery of a new image comes through in Abrams’ chatty and occasionally repetitive text. Over around 50 chapters, he cuts between the tintype story and the story of Billy and his associates.
He asserts provenance of the tintype through the Root family, while noting and dismissing the claims of Billy imposters – no death certificate allowed rumours he survived – and screen adaptations. He also notes the offhand response from committees relying on donations from wealthy men like Koch.
It’s a persuasive and intriguing tale. Undoubtedly the tintype, dated 1880, is from the 19th century. Some experts have noted the lack of paper provenance, the limitations of facial recognition software, and the slim likelihood that Billy and Garrett would have posed together.
Looking at the tintype and comparing with the authenticated Dedrick one both raises questions and answers them. Check this broadcast for yourself to make up your mind.
The book is written in a style that ensures a quick, riveting read and shares enough material to continue the investigation. If you are interested in the American West, the history of photography, or the complexities of scholarship, you might find much to enjoy here.
The Slander of Billy The Kid and the Abram Tintypes is due to be published in the coming months. My thanks to Frank Abrams for a review copy.

