Site icon LouReviews

Inconceivable / My Pro-Choice Life (Santa Monica Playhouse, Binge Fringe Festival)

The BFF aka The Binge Fringe Festival of Free Theatre – the 11th annual Santa Monica Fringe Festival – features artists, companies, and performances by Santa Monica and Los Angeles-based artists. The BFF aims to celebrate the range and depth of the human condition and the idea that theatre arts experiences are vital, transformative, and must be available for all.  On that note, all tickets and admissions to every single BFF event are free to the public.

Watching live-streamed performances from the UK, I will be reviewing as many of the shows as I can, continuing with week 5’s Inconceivable and week 4’s My Pro-Choice Life. The Binge Fringe Festival continues until 20 Nov 2026, and the live-streams can be found at Santa Monica Playhouse’s YouTube channel.

I chose to review these two shows together as they present two perspectives on women’s reproductive rights.

Inconceivable, written and performed by Alice Cutler and directed by Vincent Giovanni, is a deeply personal account of infertility, IVF and child loss. Combining humour with considerable honesty, Cutler delivers a raw and often disarming performance, sharing her family background and the expectations that shaped her own desire for motherhood. Having grown up with the seemingly conventional ideal of the white picket fence and two children, she explores what happens when the anticipated path to parenthood proves impossible without medical intervention.

Cutler takes us through the emotional and physical demands of exploring the options available, offering a frank insight into the realities of fertility treatment and the decisions women are required to make along the way. Her account also exposes the limitations and inequalities of the American healthcare system, where access to reproductive treatment is shaped by medical provision and financial considerations.

The pain of wanting a child, undergoing treatment and ultimately experiencing loss makes for a powerful and affecting piece of theatre. Although intensely personal, its emotional reach extends well beyond those who have experienced parenthood or infertility themselves.

In contrast, My Pro-Choice Life: Raised to Be an Activist and Still Trying, a solo show by Amanda Cohen, directed by Jim McCaffree, approaches reproductive rights from the perspective of political activism. Cohen traces her life as an advocate for women’s reproductive healthcare, including access to contraception and the right to safe abortion.

Rather than constructing a conventional theatrical narrative, she presents a personal and political account of a lifelong commitment to defending women’s choices over their own bodies. McCaffree introduces some surrealistic touches to the staging, adding theatrical texture to what is essentially an argument delivered through lived experience and activism.

The production’s timing is particularly significant in the aftermath of the overturning of Roe v. Wade, which removed the federal constitutional protection for abortion in the United States and allowed individual states to determine their own abortion laws. Cohen’s account highlights the consequences of this shift, particularly in states where abortion restrictions have placed considerable limitations on women’s access to reproductive healthcare. Her central concern is the extent to which women retain control over decisions that have profound consequences for their physical, emotional and social wellbeing.

Seen together, these two productions offer complementary, though distinctly different, perspectives on the politics and experience of reproduction. Inconceivable explores the anguish of wanting a child and being unable to conceive without medical assistance; My Pro-Choice Life examines the struggle to retain the right to decide whether to become a parent at all.

One is rooted in the intensely private experience of infertility and loss, the other in the public fight for reproductive freedom. Yet both expose the uncomfortable contradictions surrounding women’s reproductive choices: the expectation that women should become mothers, alongside the restrictions and obstacles they encounter when making decisions about their own bodies.

There is also an important distinction in the way the two productions communicate their arguments. Cutler’s humour and emotional vulnerability use a painful, personal tone, allowing the wider political implications to emerge through her story. Cohen, on the other hand, is more directly polemical, using her experience as an activist to make an explicit case for reproductive autonomy. While this gives My Pro-Choice Life a clear sense of purpose, its argument-led approach offers less of the dramatic and emotional development found in Inconceivable. Equally, Cutler’s deeply personal perspective, powerful as it is, does not always extend into a wider examination of the structural and political forces that determine access to fertility treatment.

Nevertheless, both productions challenge the assumption that reproductive choices are simply personal matters. They expose the extent to which healthcare provision, political ideology, religious influence and, ultimately, male-dominated decision-making structures can determine what choices are available to women. They also raise questions about whose interests are prioritised when decisions about pregnancy, fertility and motherhood are made.

Although approaching the subject from opposite ends of the reproductive experience, Inconceivable and My Pro-Choice Life share a central concern: women’s right to have agency over their own bodies and futures. Together, they make for a thought-provoking theatrical conversation about the realities of reproductive healthcare in modern America, exposing the emotional cost of its limitations and the continuing struggle for women to have their choices recognised and respected.

Exit mobile version